Windows 8
Windows 8 is a desktop operating system by Microsoft introduced in 2012, which had a tablet UI. Its server counterpart is Windows Server 2012, which introduced Aero Lite and bad Wi-Fi support.
Criticism
Windows 8 was hated for the following reasons:
- Removal of the Start button, a feature since Windows 95
- Removal of the Classic theme, you could only get it back through screwing with DWM
- Failed attempt to bring a tablet UI to the desktop
- Addition of heavy Telemetry (and where all of the invasive spyware measures really started)
- Forced updating for Windows 7 users like with Windows 10 where it smuggled itself through official Update channels and tried to silently overwrite your Windows install
- Removal of the old Open With Win32 dialog and replaced with
OpenWith.exe, a Metro/UWP based dialog where if you wanted to exit the dialog, you had to either press ESC or click outside the dialog - No obvious way to exit the Fullscreen Metro apps
- Forced sign-in to an online Microsoft account
- Start screen (Although you can bring back the old Start menu with Open-Shell)
- Charms bar
- File Explorer's new Ribbon being a confusing mess and a good example of bad UX design
- Metro being a horrid idea in general
- Minimal and flat design, keep in mind there was Aero before this
- Not many Metro apps
- Wasn't good for desktops
Like with other Windows releases and their absolute clusterfuck of a feature-set, you could easily disable some of the things Windows 8 added, like you can remove the Ribbon with OldNewExplorer and you can remove almost all of the Metro garbage with some tool I forgot the name of.
Windows 8.1
Windows 8.1 was technically a service pack and a "major" update to Windows 8. It added:
- Start button
- More metro apps
But the criticism was still very much valid, and it still had the Metro UI. But even then there were some issues with it:
- There was a start button again, but it didn't remove the Start Screen
- Did nothing to remove the atrocious Metro UI and virtually no choice to get the old Windows UI back
- Still had just some of the same problems with the previous release
- You could only get the update through the Windows Store for a while and you couldn't even use official update channels to get it
- "Better for tablets", but not any better for desktops
- Introduced more bugs and yet more exploits(?)
There weren't many notable improvements with this one other than "bugfixes" and "performance improvements", and maybe some core changes?